Hypochlorous acid is a skincare ingredient with a long history of use for wound care and infections, showing promise for treating conditions like acne and atopic dermatitis, but its effectiveness in over-the-counter products may vary due to stability issues and lack of rigorous studies.
- Hypochlorous acid (HOCl) is gaining popularity in skincare but has a long history as a wound disinfectant. - It has FDA approval for various medical uses, including wound care and infection management. - HOCl is effective in reducing microbial load in wounds and may aid in wound healing. - It shows promise in treating atopic dermatitis and acne, with some studies indicating similar efficacy to traditional treatments. - Stability of HOCl is crucial for its effectiveness; environmental factors can significantly affect it. - Over-the-counter HOCl products may vary in efficacy and stability compared to prescription formulations. - More research is needed to fully understand the effectiveness and stability of OTC HOCl products.
This is from Journal of Drugs in Dermatology in 2024 at https://jddonline.com/articles/hypochlorous-acid-blast-past-S1545961624P1024X/
1. Hypochlorous Acid 2. Dermatology 3. Skincare 4. Wound Care 5. Microbicidal
October 2024 | Volume 23 | Issue 10 | 909 | Copyright © October 2024
Published online September 24, 2024
Nikita Menta BA, Savanna I. Vidal BS, Adam Friedman MD FAAD
Department of Dermatology, George Washington University School of Medicine and Health Sciences, Washington, DC
Abstract
INTRODUCTION
Hypochlorous acid (HOCl) is one of the latest skincare ingredients to gain widespread popularity on social media. Despite newfound interest by some, the use of HOCl is certainly not new; its medicinal use, as a wound disinfectant, dates back to World War I.1 Since then, HOCl has earned FDA approval for several indications, including wound care and management of eyelid and oral infections.1 In dermatology, specifically, several stabilized HOCl formulations are in the marketplace and have been studied for various indications.2 Now, HOCl spray has made its way to social media with users incorporating it into their daily skincare routines, applying it as a post-workout disinfectant, and using it to manage acne. Herein, we review the evidence for HOCl to determine the validity behind this skincare trend.
Mechanisms of Action
HOCl is naturally produced through the body's innate immune response. It is formed through the respiratory burst pathway after myeloperoxidase-expressing cells phagocytose pathogens. Its microbicidal actions are mediated through oxidative damage to pathogens' proteins, DNA, and lipids, which can gradually lead to cytotoxicity and cell death.3 HOCl is microbicidal to many pathogens including methicillin-resistant S. aureus, S. epidermidis, E. coli, and P. aeruginosa.4 HOCl also has numerous anti-inflammatory mechanisms such as reducing the activity of histamine, leukotriene B4 (LTB4), and interleukin-2 (IL-2) and increasing the activity of transforming growth factor-beta.4
Applications in Dermatology
There are numerous dermatologic applications for HOCl, with wound care being the most common. HOCl reduces the microbial load in infected wounds in a concentration-dependent manner; at a concentration of 500 mg/L, the extent of microbial reduction is around six times greater than at 100 mg/L.2,5 HOCl can also directly contribute to wound healing success by increasing the percentage of epithelialization compared to other media, such as sterile saline solution.6 Additionally, HOCl may have a role in reducing scarring of wounds. A study comparing HOCl gel to 100% silicone gel found that HOCl gel decreased the vascularity and height of scars to a greater degree after 16 weeks.7
HOCl is also effective in the treatment of atopic dermatitis (AD)-associated pruritus. In animal studies, topical HOCl reduced scratching behavior to the same extent as 0.1% betamethasone dipropionate ointment.8 In human studies, topical HOCl reduced itch within three days with no serious adverse events.9 Another study demonstrated significantly reduced S. aureus colony counts within three minutes and after one week of treatment with HOCl.10 Reduction of S. aureus and diminished activity of histamine, IL-2, and LTB4 have been hypothesized to be primary mechanisms by which HOCl reduces AD-associated pruritus.4 HOCl has both anti-inflammatory and pro-inflammatory effects, but anti-inflammatory effects predominate.4 Specific antiinflammatory mechanisms, namely HOCl's effect on proteases, are concentration-dependent. At high concentrations, HOCl decreases protease activity causing anti-inflammatory effects, but at low concentrations, it increases protease activity causing the opposite effect.4
Finally, the role of HOCl in treating acne and seborrheic dermatitis has been previously explored. One study evaluating the efficacy of HOCl solution versus benzoyl peroxide in acne management found equivalent improvement in facial inflammatory lesions with both treatments.11 Another study investigating the efficacy of HOCl gel in managing mild-to-moderate facial and scalp seborrheic dermatitis observed a 33% improvement in Investigator Global Assessment scores within 14 days.12 More studies are needed to quantify the efficacy of HOCl in treating these conditions.
Stability of Hypochlorous Acid
While HOCl has many beneficial applications, its efficacy is highly dependent on its stability. Several variables can impact the stability of HOCl in solution, including pH and environmental factors such as sunlight, temperature, contact with air, and other compounds in solution. HOCl is stable between a pH of 3.5 and 5.5; at pH ranges above or below this, concentrations of HOCl decrease, and concentrations of reaction products increase.4 For example, at higher pHs, the concentration of sodium hypochlorite, which has less microbicidal activity than HOCl, increases.4 In addition to pH, controlling environmental factors is also essential to maintaining the stability of HOCl. One study evaluated the effect of sunlight on the shelf life of HOCl and found that chlorine reduction started on day 4 in the sunexposed solution and by day 14 in the sun-sheltered solution, highlighting that sunlight significantly decreases the stability of HOCl.13 In addition to sunlight, irradiation from an
ultraviolet lamp, contact with air, temperatures greater than 25 degrees C, and the presence of organic and inorganic compounds in solution all decrease the stability of HOCl.14 Accordingly, HOCl must be stored in cool, dark environments. Additionally, contact with air and the concentration of organic and inorganic compounds in the water used to formulate HOCl solutions must be kept to a minimum to maintain its stability.14
Over-the-Counter Hypochlorous Acid Products
Considering the very specific requirements for properly formulating and maintaining the stability of HOCl, it is crucial to carefully consider the characteristics and handling of over-the-counter (OTC) HOCl formulations. Currently, there are no guidelines for storing or handling OTC HOCl. Additionally, OTC HOCl formulations have not been studied in in-vitro or clinical studies, and thus, we have no data on their microbicidal activity. HOCl concentrations in trending OTC sprays range between 0.012% and 0.02%, which is on the lower end of concentrations that effectively reduce microbial density in wounds.5,15 Nonetheless, anecdotally, individuals with AD and acne have reported improvement in symptoms and appearance with the use of OTC HOCl sprays. While this suggests that OTC formulations have some efficacy, they likely differ in efficacy compared to stabilized, prescription formulations, due to variations in production, shipping, and handling. Even once the product reaches consumers' hands, it is vulnerable to many environmental factors; heat, in particular, is a major culprit, given that many users store it in their gym bags to use as a post-workout disinfectant.
CONCLUSION
While OTC HOCl formulations increase accessibility to this multifaceted biomolecule, consistency with respect to efficacy and stability are not known due to a lack of both in vitro and in vivo studies evaluating these formulations. Taking into account the high susceptibility of HOCl to environmental factors and variability in the production of OTC products, we can assume that the OTC HOCl formulations have different functional properties compared to their prescription counterparts. Given that we have an array of alternative FDA-approved treatment options for both AD and acne, the use of HOCl spray in place of first-line, evidence-based treatments is not advisable. However, since HOCl has a favorable safety profile, its adjunctive use is at least unlikely to be harmful. Ultimately, more studies are needed to elucidate the stability and microbicidal activity of OTC HOCl sprays.
DISCLOSURE
NM's work is funded through independent research grants from Incyte and Johnson & Johnson. SIV's work is funded through an independent research grant from Galderma.
REFERENCES
1. Boecker D, Zhang Z, Breves R, Herth F, Kramer A, Bulitta C. Antimicrobial efficacy, mode of action and in vivo use of hypochlorous acid (HOCl) for prevention or therapeutic support of infections. GMS Hyg Infect Control. 2023;18.
2. Natarelli N, Nong Y, Maloh J, et al. Hypochlorous acid: applications in dermatology. J Integr Derm. 2022. Available at: https://www.jintegrativederm.org/article/56663- hypochlorous-acid-applications-in-dermatology. Accessed August 10, 2024.
3. Ulfig A, Leichert LI. The effects of neutrophil-generated hypochlorous acid and other hypohalous acids on host and pathogens. Cell Mol Life Sci. 2021;78(2):385-414.
4. Pelgrift RY, Friedman AJ. Topical hypochlorous acid (HOCl) as a potential treatment of pruritus. Curr Derm Rep. 2013;2(3):181-190.
5. Herruzo R, Herruzo I. Antimicrobial efficacy of a very stable hypochlorous acid formula compared with other antiseptics used in treating wounds: an in-vitro study on micro-organisms with or without biofilm. J Hosp Infect. 2020;105(2):289-294.
6. Pastar I, Stojadinovic O, Yin NC, et al. Epithelialization in wound healing: a comprehensive review. Adv Wound Care (New Rochelle). 2014;3(7):445-464.
7. Bucko AD, Draelos Z, Dubois JC, Jones TM. A double-blind, randomized study to compare microcyn scar management hydrogel, K103163, and Kelo-cote scar gel for hypertrophic or keloid scars. Presented at the 14th Annual Caribbean Dermatology Symposium; January 2015; St. Maarten.
8. Fukuyama T, Martel BC, Linder KE, Ehling S, Ganchingco JR, Baumer W. Hypochlorous acid is antipruritic and anti-inflammatory in a mouse model of atopic dermatitis. Clin Exp Allergy. 2018;48(1):78-88.
9. Berman B, Nestor M. Investigator-blinded, randomized study evaluation of HOCl in the treatment of atopic dermatitis-associated pruritus. SKIN. 2017;1:40.
10. Sasai-Takedatsu M, Kojima T, Yamamoto A, et al. Reduction of Staphylococcus aureus in atopic skin lesions with acid electrolytic water - a new therapeutic strategy for atopic dermatitis. Allergy. 1997;52(10):1012-1016.
11. Tirado-Sanchez A, Ponce-Olivera RM. Efficacy and tolerance of superoxidized solution in the treatment of mild to moderate inflammatory acne. A double-blinded, placebo-controlled, parallel-group, randomized, clinical trial. J Dermatolog Treat. 2009;20(5):289-292.
12. Draelos Z. An evaluation of oculus sebuderm - Microcyn based gel on mild to moderate facial and scalp seborrheic dermatitis. Poster presented at the 10th Annual Coastal Dermatology Symposium; September 2014; Sonoma, CA.
13. Rossi-Fedele G, Dogramaci EJ, Steier L, et al. Some factors influencing the stability of Sterilox(®), a super-oxidised water. Br Dent J. 2011;210(12):E23.
14. Ishihara M, Murakami K, Fukuda K, et al. Stability of weakly acidic hypochlorous acid solution with microbicidal activity. Biocontrol Sci. 2017;22(4):223-227.
15. Skinskool. The Wonders of Tower 28 Hypochlorous Acid - Affordable HOCl Sprays to Add to your Skincare Regimen. Available at: https://skinskoolbeauty.com/dupetalk/ the-wonders-of-hypochlorous-acid-affordable-hypochlorous-acid-sprays-to-add-to-your-skincare-regimen. Accessed August 18, 2024.